Thursday, August 11, 2005

The Idea of America

I have heard this phrase at least a couple times in the last week or so. "The idea of America," they say. Bono said that he loves the idea of America, Peter Jennings felt the same way (and obtained America citizenship), and I guess I could see where they're going with this.

While I might have my issues–that I have brought up in previous posts–with America in its current state, I think I could go there with both these fellas.

The idea of a nation of people where anyone could come and make a life for themselves, escape oppression, find hope, where the Earth seemed rich with blessing, where the government and people lead the way by example (how very much like ancient China) instead of by force, where the rich care for the poor in such a way that all find their stomachs full... and perhaps we find no longer rich and poor as distinctions.

But I am reminded that this is not the case in so many ways today. For as much energy as I could spend supporting an argument for higher tax burden for those who make more in this nation, feeling that it is their moral responsibility to take care of those who cannot take care of themselves, I do still believe that inspiration is far better than legislation. In fact, this morning, when I heard on NPR that the state of California is going to raise like 100 million dollars by taxing the rich, I kind of shuddered. I mean, is legislation the best means necessary? Will people not give out of the goodness of their own hearts? I wonder. I really do.

Martin Luther King, Jr. said he wanted to bring about inspiration, not legislation in furthering his cause that all men and women would be recognized as being created equal.

But looking at how things "actually" work in America, it is hard for me to buy into this "idea of America" sometimes because I think most people have a different "idea of America." The myths generated by television shows and movies and whatnot do not generally promote these ideals, but an alternative set of ideals that are very egocentric, hoarding, materialistic, and disconnected.

Sounds a bit like the idea of Christianity to me. There are so many people who have so many different ideas of how it's supposed to work, what is at its heart. Moral legislation or inspiration? I read somewhere recently that when a lighthouse does it's job, it doesn't need to send off fireworks to say, "Hey! Over here! Look, a lighthouse!" because it is a lighthouse and by its very nature, people will see it for what it is.

I wonder if any of this makes sense or resonates with any of you... or perhaps infuriates you? Just questions. Just trying to help in the re-imagining of a better world. Just trying to figure out what that means for me and my family and friends.

5 comments:

Sled Dog said...

I believe you express the constant frustration of any one who longs to experience "kindgom living" here on earth. As long as sin is present, we will always battle injustice, greed and suppression. That doesn't mean we give up, it simply means until we are with God in heaven, life will never be truly peaceful.

I can't think that the fate of America will end up like so many "great" civilizations of the past...crushed from the weight of its own pride, greed, etc. At the same time, I am amazed that Americans seem to be seared with some sort of Judeo-Christian conscience.

Sled Dog said...

EDIT: I meant to write:

" I imagine that the fate of America will end up...yeah, I think she's on course for trouble...

Danae said...

reading your thoughts makes me so happy. i love the way you think. it's like a breath of fresh air when i'm surrounded by people who... well, just don't think the same way. ;)

i miss you and holly greatly. hope you're well... P

Anonymous said...

There is a lot of value in coin values .

Anonymous said...

I agee with your post. Hey check this out--You're Going To LOVE This Site. Visit this Free Software Site!